Digital Journal Blog

The Ultimate Comparison of Reels, TikTok, and Shorts

In recent years, short-form vertical videos have exploded in popularity among social media platforms aiming to capitalize on new digital content consumption habits. Instagram Reels, TikTok, and YouTube Shorts have emerged as leaders in enabling creators to produce entertaining and engaging short video content designed for mobile screens.

This guide provides an in-depth comparison of the features, capabilities, metrics, and overall strengths of Reels, TikTok, and Shorts as they compete for user attention and loyalty. Analyzing the distinctions helps paint a clearer picture of each platform’s strategy.

Table of Contents

TikTok vs. Reels vs. Shorts by the Numbers
Social Shopping
Final Comparison


Instagram Reels Overview

Instagram Reels was launched in 2020 as the platform’s short-form video feature designed to directly compete with the hugely popular app TikTok. Reels allow users to create multi-clip videos up to 60 seconds with creative tools like audio, AR effects, filters, text overlays, remixing of content etc.

Instagram pushes Reels to users based on interests, topics and interactions rather than just followers. Reels offer creators a path to going viral on Instagram the way TikTok powers user-generated content discovery.

TikTok’s Overview

TikTok pioneered the short-form vertical video format that has become a global phenomenon since its launch in 2016. Its seamlessly endless feed is powered by AI recommendation algorithms that surface personalized videos aligned to each user’s interests and engagement.

TikTok empowers creativity through features like captions, green screen effects, live streaming, and duet reactions. It has over 1 billion monthly active users and has introduced ad offerings to further monetization.

YouTube’s Shorts Overview

YouTube Shorts refers to short-form vertical videos under 60 seconds introduced by YouTube in 2020 as its version of short video content to compete with TikTok. Shorts are designed for capturing trends, expression and creativity via mobile cameras.

YouTube Shorts are tightly integrated across the main YouTube app enabling creators to leverage the entire YouTube ecosystem from the same accounts, content library, monetization avenues, analytics etc.

TikTok vs. Reels vs. Shorts by the Numbers

Analyzing key metrics and engagement statistics provides tangible insights into the current landscape and momentum across TikTok, Instagram Reels, and YouTube Shorts as the platforms vie for market share. Some numbers to highlight:

Time Spent on Screens

TikTok has achieved unparalleled user stickiness with average time spent on the app per user per day at approximately 89 minutes currently. This highlights the gravitational engagement created by TikTok’s highly accurate recommendations and video effects.

In comparison, average time spent daily is around 53 minutes on Instagram as a whole, and 41 minutes on YouTube as per latest data. TikTok outpaces rivals here.

Application Downloads

In terms of global application downloads from app stores, TikTok has amassed over 3 billion downloads to date as of Q3 2022 reflecting its meteoric rise.

Instagram overall has reached over 2 billion downloads leveraging its entrenched userbase. YouTube has asl over 5 billion downloads historically indicating its scale.

Prominent Users

TikTok has birthed a new wave of social media superstars and influencers including the likes of Charli D’Amelio, Addison Rae and Bella Poarch who rule short video content.

On Instagram, celebrity figures like Selena Gomez and the Kardashian-Jenner family have massive followings they leverage for Reels. YouTube Shorts sees Jimmy Donaldson aka MrBeast as a top creator on the platform.


In terms of monetization, TikTok is estimated to hit nearly $12 billion in worldwide ad revenues in 2022. Instagram likely made over $120 billion in ad revenues in 2021 tapping into shopping and its breadth of content. YouTube made $28.8 billion in ad revenues in 2021 denoting the moneymaking potential of short video ads.


Social Shopping

Given how social media is embedded into daily lives, commerce integrated into platforms like Instagram and TikTok has grown tremendously. Their shoppable video and post capabilities enable everything from product discovery to quick checkout.

Instagram Shopping

Instagram provides robust shopping integration focused mainly on linking ecommerce sites rather than in-app transactions. This includes shoppable posts with tagged products, personalized recommendations via the Explore tab, shoppable Live videos, and Instagram stores that simplify mobile checkout.

Over 130 million people tap to reveal tags in shopping posts each month demonstrating highly engaged audiences ready to purchase.

TikTok Shopping

TikTok has aggressively pushed into social commerce with direct in-app purchasing capabilities powered by integration with Shopify, WooCommerce, Square and others. Viewers can check out without leaving TikTok.

Products featured by creators can be instantly shopped by tapping on timed shopping tags that link to listings. TikTok is estimated to be driving over $300 million in monthly sales, establishing it as a competitor in ecommerce beyond just advertising.

The immersive embed of shopping into short videos on TikTok and Instagram creates a discovery-driven experience that offers excitement and convenience around purchases. And video-enabled storytelling helps brands connect better with consumers through relatable content.


Each platform employs unique strategies aimed at maximizing quality user engagement. This reflects their underlying priorities and philosophies.


A core strength of TikTok is its unparalleled algorithmic recommendation engines that surface creative, funny and captivating videos continuously tailored to individual user taste. The app has completely redefined viral content distribution at scale.

TikTok also promotes high engagement through features like duets, user-generated challenges, reactive commentary, and live interactivity. The app focuses on fueling obsession more so than just casual viewing.


Instagram prioritizes authenticity and original perspectives in its content feed rankings aimed at avoiding the over-commercialized influencer vibe that took over its discoverability previously.

Story sharing and disappearing content help drive more visceral engagement. And supplementary features like IGTV and Live shopping expand monetization beyond just advertising.


YouTube cultivates strong loyalty driven by content variety and subscriber exclusivity bolstering consistent engagement. Viewers form deep connections with creators.

Tactics like end screens prompts, cards, watermarks and epidodes further extend watch time. Comments foster a sense of community interaction around videos augmented by live chat features.

Final Comparison

In summary, while the short-form vertical video category is heating up, each contender brings differentiated strengths into the arena. TikTok maintains its position as the nexus of viral short video given its culture-shaping algorithmic distribution leveraging AI.

Instagram Reels benefits handsomely from infiltrating TikTok-style content within its entrenched ecosystem of influencers and brands. And YouTube Shorts expands creators’ reach by tightly integrating with the main YouTube app used by over 2 billion monthly viewers.

The space promises to evolve rapidly as consumer mobile behaviors shift and new innovations emerge. But currently TikTok, Instagram and YouTube have staked out leading positions with distinct competitive advantages.

Popular Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Topic(s) of Interest*


Welcome to our Instagram , where you’ll find links to all of our most recent and exciting Instagram posts!

We’re thrilled to share our pictures and videos with you, and we wish you find them as inspiring and entertaining as we do.

At Digital Journal Blog, we believe that Instagram is an incredibly powerful tool for connecting with our audience and sharing our story. That’s why we’re constantly updating our Instagram feed with new and interesting content that showcases our products, services, and values.

We appreciate your visit and look forward to connecting with you on Instagram!